Add Your Review
Thanks for visiting JB Quimby's. We'd love to have your feedback!
Our Latest Reviews
We enjoyed the reuben immensely. But the BIG draw for me and my mom was the AMAZING, YES AMAZING, Bloody Mary with all the fixings! I have not had better!!!!
I am in the constant search for the best Reuben ever, so in every new restaurant I go to, I try their Reuben. I tried Quimby's Reuben for the first time almost 20 years ago, and I have yet to find anywhere that comes close to it! It continues to be my go to meal at Quimby's after all this time. The quality rye bread, the REAL corned beef (none of that sliced deli meat here), and tater tots with a side of buffalo garlic sauce...perfection! I'm making myself hungry just thinking about it.
Best plate in Rochester!
Best wings in Rochester
Fries and tots are good, still enjoy home fries better which they do have on occasion!
Great burgers, one of my more frequently ordered items
The steak was perfect. Literally perfect. It was placed on top of 2 garlic baguettes that soaked up the steak juices. Yum. I ordered mine with salt potatoes. Very unique. Plus great service and atmosphere. Spectacular local pub. I have had larger parties there and still receive the same great service. My favorite restaurant.
A bit dry. Needed more sauce. Overall I'd give it a 7 out of 10
THIS IS THE BEST garbage plate you will ever have. I have tried so many around town but this one always hits the spot...oh let me tell you about the pulled pork melt .. so my fiance goes here a lot for lunch with his coworkers. One day he brought home this pulled pork melt. I woke up in the middle of the night looking for a snack so I warmed that sandwich and OMG that was the best late night snack I have ever had. it didn't even have that weird leftover pork taste. All of this to say whatever dish you get from here is always going to be very tasty.
The chicken quesadillas are fantastic!!! I order them every time I go in here now. They are a perfect meal to have for lunch and I can never even finish them, as the serving is so generous! I always end up bringing half of it home with me. I would recommend these to any one who loves quesadillas...they are the best I have ever had.
We attend almost every Thursday "Burger Night" and have NEVER been disappointed...FNTASTIC FOOD & FANTASTIC SERVICE, ❤️❤️❤️ the place, been a regular for years...bill/jeanette
Used to be a go-to for me, still enjoy on occasion!
Great wings, some of the best around. Favorites are garlic parm, mild, medium and hot have good flavors! Recently enjoyed Jamaican jerk as well